In a city that calls itself the Cheese Capital of the World, the souvenir to bring home is cheese. Shopping in Plymouth starts at a cheese counter on Mill Street, runs past an antique mall listed by Travel Wisconsin and a handful of small shops downtown, and then heads out on county roads to orchards, a sugarbush and a garden center. The big-box stores sit together on the east side, so the errands and the browsing rarely mix.
Distances below are straight-line from downtown, measured from each listing's map pin, and shop hours change with the seasons, so check before driving out to a farm.
Sponsored
Cheese first, on East Mill Street
Start at the Cheese Counter and Dairy Heritage Center at 133 East Mill Street, right in the middle of downtown. Its shelves carry Wisconsin-made cheeses, dips and spreads, curds such as Henning's Two Tone Cheddar and Garlic & Dill, Sartori MontAmore Cheddar and Masters Gallery 5 Year Aged Cheddar. It also packs cheese gift boxes, which solves the question of what to bring home.
Sartori and Masters Gallery are not just labels here. Wikipedia lists four cheese processing facilities in Plymouth, Sargento, Masters Gallery, Sartori and Great Lakes Cheese, and the city calls itself the Cheese Capital of the World. A touch-screen exhibit at the counter tells the story of cheese in Plymouth, and the deli makes grilled cheese sandwiches, including one with jalapeño peppers, if you shop hungry.
For meat to go with the cheese, Schwaller Meats at 633 Eastern Avenue, about 0.35 mile east of downtown, is a butcher shop for steaks and roasts that also stocks cheese, smoked fish, local maple syrup and Seroojy bars. Tietz's Piggly Wiggly at 1411 Eastern Avenue has a deli and bakery and carries Boar's Head meats and cheeses.
Antiques and small shops downtown
Downtown shopping is a walk along Mill Street rather than a mall. Travel Wisconsin lists Shoppes on Mill Street at 412 East Mill Street as a multi-dealer mall with a general line of antiques, collectibles and furniture. Its listing gives no hours, so call ahead to check it is still open and when before you plan a morning around it.
Up North News, in an October 2025 roundup of things to do in Plymouth, told visitors to fit in local shops between the murals and the food: Allechant Boutique, Books and More, Caan's Garden & Gifts, Cain's Bridal Wreath and Maggie's Closet. Shops change hands, so check that each one is still trading before you go.
Between shops, the coffee shops in Plymouth are on the same street, with Moxie at 301 East Mill and Hartman's Bakery at 433 East Mill.
For lunch, Plymouth restaurants run from Mill Street pizza to German fare at the Depot.
Musicians have a reason to stop on South Stafford Street: Roots Acoustic Music Company at number 11 repairs and restores stringed instruments and builds custom resophonic and acoustic guitars. It describes itself as a workshop, so bring the guitar that needs work.
Thrift and home goods
Two stores cover secondhand and decor, one in town and one on Highway 57.
Orchards, maple syrup and the farmers market
The farm shopping is out of town, on the roads that ring Plymouth. In town, the market comes to you on Thursdays.
The Plymouth Farmers Market runs on Thursdays from 3 to 6 p.m. at Stayer Park, according to its listing, about 0.1 mile from the Cheese Counter. Area farmers, business owners and nonprofits run it with support from Nourish Farms, and the stalls carry local honey, apple cider syrup and produce such as yellow and purple cherry tomatoes.
Restoration Orchards and Market on Willow Road, about 4 miles northeast of downtown, grows more than 120 varieties of heirloom apples and presses its own cider. The market is open Thursdays through Sundays, according to its listing, with berries, baked goods, organic eggs, Wisconsin cheeses, frozen meats, pantry staples and gifts.
Log Cabin Orchard on County Road E, about 2.3 miles south, holds u-pick days for Honeycrisp and McIntosh apples and sells cider by the jug, cider slushies, apple hand pies and Aronia syrup. Its 1870s log cabin holds games and historical relics.
Springdale Farm on Silver Spring Lane, about 4.4 miles southwest, is a 35-acre organic vegetable farm that supplies about 700 CSA members in southeastern Wisconsin. For the garden, Moraine Gardens on Sumac Road, about 2.7 miles southeast, grows annuals, perennials, vegetables and trees.
Sheboygan, about 13 miles east on the lake, has its own market, and the Sheboygan farmers market also names several of these Plymouth farms.
Errands, gear and the big-box stores
Plymouth's big-box stores cluster on the east side, along Eastern Avenue and Walton Drive, between about 1.7 and 1.8 miles from downtown.
Nearby, Walmart Supercenter at 428 Walton Drive has groceries, a pharmacy, auto care and a vision center, and Dollar Tree is at 540 Walton Drive.
Country Equipment Service on County Road O, about 1.7 miles northeast, sells new and used equipment and tunes up snowblowers and lawnmowers. For a bottle to take home, Cut-Rate Liquor at 1516 Eastern Avenue carries bourbon, whiskey, beer and wine, up to allocated bourbons.
A day of shopping in Plymouth fits around the rest of a visit to Plymouth, from the cheese arch to Road America.
Frequently asked questions
Published October 12, 2026
