Plymouth WI Pizza from Build-Your-Own to a BLT Pie

Two old buildings on Mill Street, about 0.3 mile apart, serve the sit-down pizza downtown, and a county-road bar east of town puts bacon and lettuce on its pie. For Plymouth pizza that means DeO's for build-your-own with a gluten-free crust option, Antoinette's for homemade pizza in a former Ford garage, and Roots Bar & Grill for a BLT pizza.

Delivery comes from Domino's on the east side, and Sweet Basil serves Italian plates for anyone who wants pasta instead. Distances below are straight-line from the center of downtown, measured from each listing's map pin.

DeO's: build your own on East Mill Street

In summer, Travel Wisconsin says, there is a deck surrounded by flowering plants, which is the seat to ask for on a warm night. Build-your-own suits a table that cannot agree, and the gluten-free crust settles the other usual argument.

Menu and pet sites list it as D. E. O'Malley's or DeO'Malley's Pizza Pub at the same address. An online menu dated around 2023 shows specialty pizzas on traditional or thin crust and says every pizza can be made on a small gluten-free crust. Menus change, so confirm the crusts and toppings when you order.

BringFido lists the patio as dog-friendly on weekends, with about fifty seats, which helps if you are travelling with a dog. Travel Wisconsin's listing is undated and gives no hours, so call 920-892-8485 before you head over.

Antoinette's: homemade pizza in a 1929 garage

Its listing says portions are generous and that the mac and cheese can stretch to more than one meal, so a pizza and a side can feed a family. Antoinette's is closed Mondays and Tuesdays and open Wednesday through Sunday, per its listing, and the number to call is 920-892-2161.

Travel Wisconsin adds hand-rolled mozzarella sticks and Signature Spiral Chips as homemade starters. The restaurant's own site names a brat, caramelized onion and arugula pizza, which is about as Sheboygan County as a pizza gets.

The two downtown spots are about 0.3 mile apart on Mill Street, so you can walk from one to the other in a few minutes and compare.

Roots Bar & Grill: the BLT pizza

Roots Bar & Grill on County Road C, about 4.6 miles east of downtown, is the out-of-town pizza stop. Its listing describes a BLT pizza with smoky bacon and a crispy crust, alongside prime rib with green beans, a salad bar and cheese curds.

It is a bar with tap beer, so it suits a supper on the way to or from Sheboygan more than a family pizza night. Roots also offers a fish fry to take home, which comes up again in the fish fry section below.

Delivery and a late slice

Domino's at 26 South Highland Avenue, about 0.9 mile east of downtown, is the chain option for delivery, carryout and dine-in. For a hotel room after a long day, delivery is the realistic answer; check that your address is in the delivery area.

Plymouth's hotels sit from downtown Mill Street out to the east side, so check the delivery area when you order. The rooms themselves are compared in the Plymouth hotels roundup.

Choosing a pizza place in Plymouth

Pick by the night you want. For a group that wants to argue over toppings, or anyone who needs a gluten-free crust, DeO's is the downtown answer.

For a family meal with leftovers and something other than pizza on the table, Antoinette's has the bigger menu, as long as it is not a Monday or Tuesday.

For a bar supper with a twist on the classic, try the BLT pizza at Roots, and for a night in at the hotel or a rental house, Domino's delivers.

All four sit within about 4.6 miles of downtown, and the two Mill Street places are within a few minutes' walk of the arts center and the Cheese Counter.

If you want more than pizza

Sweet Basil, about 1.9 miles east of downtown on Walton Drive, serves Italian plates like linguine and chicken Parmesan, with a large patio, according to its listing.

The full spread of kitchens in town, from the German supper at the Depot to the drive-in burgers, is laid out in restaurants in Plymouth.

Pizza and a beer go together, and the taps on Mill Street are a short walk from both downtown pizza places.

Pizza or a Friday fish fry?

On a Friday in Plymouth, pizza competes with the fish fry, and Roots does both.

If perch or bluegill wins the vote, the downtown taverns and county-road bars that serve Plymouth's Friday fish fry include Roots.

For the rest of an evening, from the arts center to the brewery, see what to do in Plymouth after dark and by day.