Absolutely amazing dining experience. Food is delicious and cooked to perfection. The atmosphere and service are so welcoming. We really enjoyed the dinner and will definitely be back.
Serving Italian favorites with a large patio
Unassuming spot with a large patio serving Italian favorites like linguine & chicken Parmesan.
Absolutely amazing dining experience. Food is delicious and cooked to perfection. The atmosphere and service are so welcoming. We really enjoyed the dinner and will definitely be back.
We try to come here every year when we’re in town and this year did not disappoint! They are under new ownership with an amazing new menu. They must be doing something right because the dining room was packed so we ate outside. You could see the waitstaff was doing a great job trying to keep up. We gave them all a little grace because we could see how busy they were. Our pasta and pizza were amazing, bruschetta was delicious. Good job everyone!
I had never been to Sweet Basil and decided to give it a shot since it's reopening and change of ownership. The place was understandably pretty quiet on a Tuesday afternoon. The atmosphere is nice. The dining room is comfortable and decor looks good. From my understanding they had it refurbished, but as I said, I'd never been to the old Sweet Basil so cant speak to changes. My server was nice and attentive. I tried to Bruschetta appetizer. I liked the crispy bread used. However, it was absolutely swimming in Balsamic. Every piece was beginning to get soggy from sitting on a plate absolutely covered in it. The topping of tomatoes was oddly almost too sweet. I ended up scraping most of it off. Just need some tweaking for better balance I think. The pizza I got was very delicious. Good crust. Just the right balance between fluffy but not too thick. Toppings were good. Cheese was gooey and stretchy. I really enjoyed this. My final note - from where I was seated in the dining room, I heard the kitchen area throughout most of my meal. Which I wasn't worried about - I was near the door and the place was pretty quiet. However, I became very uncomfortable when about halfway through my meal the arguments started. I heard staff yelling at each other, swearing, etc and who I assume to be a manager trying to step in and tell them to stop arguing. It was pretty off putting. I'd give them another try perhaps at a more busy time and bringing some friends along. Overall it was a fairly pleasant experience. I understand only being 1 week into their relaunch there are some kinks to work out and struggles to navigate.
It was our first time here for Valentine's and our 10 year anniversary and it was very good! We each had two drinks, muscles for appetizer, prime rib and the scallop risotto for dinner. We definitely will be back 🙂
Local time · GMT-6

While you're here
Everything local in Plymouth, all in one place.

Enjoy breakfast, lunch, and catering services in Plymouth

Hand-crafted maple syrup and a seasonal open house experience

Serving German specialties, ribs, and steaks in a historic depot building

Enjoy pizza, pulled pork mac and cheese, and pretzel sticks

Serving family restaurant fare in Plymouth, Wisconsin

Serving brisket, pulled pork, and smoked wings in Plymouth

All-day breakfast and lunch menu options in Plymouth

Serving specialty coffee, breakfast pastries, and sandwiches in Plymouth
Is this your business?
Reach people across town and nearby with Sweet Basil | Italian Restaurant
Claim it free to post events and updates that show up on town pages, event calendars and local recommendations — and help local and AI search find you.
Claim this listing