Thrift Stores in Menomonie WI, From Dollar Racks to Vinyl

Grace Church, Hope Bargain Center, Goodwill and TC Vintage compared from local press, their own pages and dated reviews.

Menomonie's secondhand shopping runs from a church shop that prices everything at a dollar or less, by its own account, to a vintage store on Broadway selling vinyl and speakers, so the range is wider than the word thrift suggests. Anyone typing thrift stores Menomonie WI into a search bar will find four shops that answer to the name in very different ways. This guide covers them in turn: Grace Church Thrift Shop on 451st Avenue, Hope Bargain Center on North Broadway, the Goodwill on Hils Court and TC Vintage on Broadway Street South. The first three are charity stores and the fourth is a curated vintage shop, which makes it a different kind of hunt.

Measured in a straight line from the town centre, Goodwill is the farthest north at about 2.7 miles, Hope Bargain Center is about 1.6 miles north, Grace Church is about 2.4 miles to the south and TC Vintage is about 0.5 miles away. Each shop is described from its own pages, local press and the dated Google reviews on file, and the complaints are reported along with the praise.

Sponsored

Grace Church Thrift Shop: the one-dollar rule

Grace Church Thrift Shop sells donated books, clothes, cooking ware, knick-knacks, toys and fabric from Grace Episcopal Church, on 451st Avenue next to the Pinewood Golf Course.

The shop's own page says everything is priced at a dollar or less and lists Friday and Saturday, 10am to 3pm.

It sits about 2.4 miles from the town centre, the farthest south of the four.

The page sums up the idea as "Saving Money, Saving Grace" and invites anyone in need, such as a family looking for children's clothes or a prom dress, to stop by. A Stoutonia profile, which carries no year, says volunteers run the shop, that it began in April 2011 to help the financially struggling church and that it now fills the church's whole first floor, which displaced some Sunday school rooms. The same profile quotes volunteer Pat Kell saying the shop was meant to help the church but also gave back to the community.

Google shows 4.9 from 18 reviews, and the reviews on file describe friendly and welcoming staff, a clean and organized shop and prices one reviewer called unbelievable. A reviewer in October 2025 wrote that knowing a late mother's clothes were going to a good cause made it easier to let them go. Google lists a wheelchair-accessible entrance and parking.

The page carries an undated closure notice for 5 and 6 November that this guide cannot confirm is current, so check ThriftGrace on Facebook or call 715-235-7072 before driving out. With only two opening days, this is the stop to plan around rather than drop into.

Hope Bargain Center: the North Broadway mission store

Hope Bargain Center, at 1230 North Broadway Street, is a Hope Gospel Mission store selling clothing, shoes, accessories, home decor and books, and Volume One's page says new items are added daily.

The store's own page lists Monday to Saturday, 10am to 6pm, closed Sundays, with donations accepted during the same hours.

It is about 1.6 miles from the town centre.

Hope Gospel Mission describes its work as Christ-centered, life-transforming help for people facing hunger and homelessness, and its store page invites visitors to shop, donate and change lives. Volume One reported in 2019 that the Bargain Centers in Eau Claire, Mondovi and Menomonie, along with the Building Hope reuse store in Eau Claire, cover more than 70 percent of the costs of the mission's shelters, education, work-training and auto donation programs. An operations director told Volume One then that the aim was to give customers a full retail experience at thrift prices.

Google shows 4.5 from 115 reviews. A reviewer in October 2026 said they had not found jigsaw puzzles made from actual photos anywhere else, and another in April 2026 found a Fenton colonial blue hobnail fairy lamp shade for six dollars. Prices draw the sharpest comments: a June 2026 reviewer who loves the store called it a little overpriced, and a one-star reviewer in March 2026 said prices were rising on donated goods and that items marked "B" did not get the 50 percent discount posted. Check the posted discount signs against the receipt before leaving.

Hope Bargain Center is about 0.6 miles from the Hampton Inn & Suites, and Google lists wheelchair-accessible parking, entrance, seating and restroom.

Goodwill on Hils Court: the chain store with a job-training mission

Menomonie Goodwill Retail Store and Training Center, at 2500 Hils Court, sells pre-owned clothing and housewares, and Volume One's page adds used furniture and a seasonal selection of donated costumes and props.

Goodwill's site lists store hours of 9am to 9pm and donation hours of 8am to 9pm daily in a table that is not specific to Menomonie, so confirm before a special trip.

It is about 2.7 miles from the town centre.

Wikipedia traces Goodwill to 1902, when the minister Edgar Helms of Morgan Memorial Methodist Chapel in Boston gathered used household goods and clothing, then trained and hired unemployed people to mend them. Goodwill North Central Wisconsin's site says an average donation funds about three hours of job training and that on average 90 cents of each sales dollar goes back into the mission.

Google shows 3.8 from 242 reviews, below the other three, and three of the five on file give two stars. A January 2026 reviewer called it a large, fairly clean store with a big clothing selection and prices a little high, while a July 2026 reviewer found prices high and said their coupons had expired. A February 2026 reviewer who buys used books said Goodwill stores in Minnesota use flat book prices and that some books here cost as much as $7 each, so check book tags before the register. An August 2026 reviewer said VIP rewards earned at the Hudson and New Richmond stores were not accepted here, and another said that a donation drop-off brought no thank-you and no offer of a receipt, so ask for a receipt if you want one.

The store is about 0.18 miles from the Menomonie 7 Theatre and about 0.5 miles from the Hampton Inn & Suites, and Google lists a wheelchair-accessible entrance and parking. Pick Goodwill for sheer volume and the late hours its site lists.

TC Vintage on Broadway: records, speakers and clothing racks

TC Vintage, at 633 Broadway Street South, sells vintage clothing, vinyl records, audio equipment and home goods.

Volume One reported in July 2023 that the shop, formerly Town & Country Antiques II, had a heavier focus on vintage clothing, vinyl, speakers, jewelry and CDs, was about a third the size of the old space and had a new fitting room.

It sits about 0.5 miles from the town centre.

The shop opened under the new name on June 6, 2023, and owner Grant, whose mother Sylvia owns the original Town & Country Antiques, said the smaller space helped the shop focus on quality products rather than quantity. After an electrical fire in late May 2025 destroyed the Town & Country building on Main Street East, Volume One reported in October 2025 that TC Vintage housed inventory from 25 former vendors over the summer. Town & Country reopened in early September 2025 at 632 Broadway Street South with 12 vendors, a separate antiques business on the same street.

Google shows 4.5 from 8 reviews. A September 2026 reviewer called the owner downright awesome with an incredible selection of just about whatever you are into, and a February 2026 reviewer who came in to look at amps said they left with a wealth of information and a beautiful addition to their home. One May 2026 review gave a single star with the words "Appears closed for business", while a September 2026 review describes a visit and an October 2026 five-star rating has no text, so ring 715-231-2026 before a special trip. Google's hours, read in November 2026, show Monday and Tuesday closed, 10am to 5pm Wednesday to Saturday and 11am to 4pm Sunday.

The shop is about 0.1 miles from the Mabel Tainter and about 0.03 miles from Acoustic Café, and Google lists a wheelchair-accessible entrance and parking. Expect a curated vintage shop rather than a charity thrift store, and a better fit for records and clothing than for housewares.

Planning a thrift day across all four

Going by the hours each source lists, Friday and Saturday are the only days when all four are open at once, since Grace Church opens only then and Hope is closed on Sunday. Taken from north to south the stops run Goodwill, then Hope Bargain Center about 1.1 miles away, then TC Vintage about 1.4 miles beyond that, then Grace Church about 2.3 miles farther on. Those are straight-line figures, so allow for the roads.

Pick Grace for the lowest tags, Hope for housewares and the odd collectible, Goodwill for volume and TC Vintage for records and clothing. Weigh the price comments before expecting bargains, because reviewers of Hope and Goodwill both raised prices while Grace's own page promises a dollar or less.

What this guide cannot tell you

Stock and tag prices change daily, so this guide gives none beyond what reviewers dated themselves. Antiques are a separate hunt, and Midwest Weekends describes an unusually large number of interesting antiques shops downtown near the Mabel Tainter, though the page's dates are unclear. Other vintage shops have come and gone in recent years: the Menomonie Minute reported BarbaLynn's Vintage behind the Raw Deal in February 2023 and Volume One reported UpCreek Vintage opening on Broadway in February 2024, but Volume One's October 2025 account refers to UpCreek's former owner, and this guide has not confirmed whether BarbaLynn's is trading today.

For the rest of a weekend away from the racks, a Menomonie weekend beyond the shops gathers the theatre, the brewery and the trail.

Between a dollar at Grace, a mission at Hope and Goodwill and a record crate at TC Vintage, the search for a thrift store in Menomonie WI has more than one answer.

Frequently asked questions

Published November 2, 2026

You might also like

See all