Ted's on Main Street East, Toppers a block over, wood-fired Lucette and Pizza Hut, compared from reviews and each kitchen's own pages.
Two of Menomonie's pizza kitchens sit about 0.06 miles apart on Main Street East, one a family-run parlor that has served the town since 1970 and the other a chain whose page promises hours until 3 AM. Typing pizza Menomonie into a phone turns up four kitchens this guide covers, Ted's Pizza Palace and Toppers Pizza downtown, a wood-fired oven at Lucette Brewing on Hudson Road and a Pizza Hut out on Highway 25. Each answers a different kind of hunger, and the recent Google reviews are candid about where each one stumbles.
Wikipedia places the city centre at the south end of Lake Menomin, and measured from there Ted's and Toppers are about 0.3 miles away, Lucette is about 1.0 mile away and Pizza Hut is about 2.6 miles away.
Sponsored
Ted's Pizza Palace: Main Street East since 1970
Volume One's 2020 anniversary article names Ted Haspais as the original owner and says the dough, sauces and meatballs have not changed over the years, while newer toppings include gyro meat, roasted tomatoes and pineapple. The same article recommends the Mama Mia, which it calls the most popular pie, along with the Zeus, the Greek Special and the House Special. An October 2022 Volume One feature picked the Zetsy Neesta, a pie named after the owner's mom that carries four-pepper cilantro sauce, grilled chicken or gyro, feta and slow-roasted tomatoes, and it warns that anyone who dislikes cilantro may not enjoy it.
Volume One's page for the restaurant adds that it makes its own sausage, sauces and crust and offers gluten-free options. Visit Eau Claire's Menomonie day-trip page sends pizza seekers to Ted's for pizza that is always homemade and fresh, with Greek fare such as gyros on the side (the page is undated).
In the reviews quoted here, the complaints are more about service than food. A September 2026 reviewer praised the greeting and the well-timed appetizer and meal, while a February 2026 reviewer thought the pizza was okay and had to go to the counter for drink refills. Older reviews add texture: a 2024 diner reported that an Italian Beef was big enough to cut into four pieces and share, a 2024 customer of decades called the tzatziki the best around but found the gyro pita cracking, and a 2023 family loved the Zeus pie with its thinly sliced tomatoes and tzatziki but waited an hour for it.
Google's hours show Ted's closed on Mondays and closing at 9 PM or 10 PM on the other days, so a Monday pizza plan belongs to Toppers or Pizza Hut. Anyone building an evening around a show at the Mabel Tainter Theater will find Ted's about 0.06 miles from the theater's door, and about 0.09 miles from the Cobblestone Inn & Suites.
Volume One's 2023 Best of roundup put Ted's third for best restaurant in Menomonie and praised its hand-crafted pizza pies.
Toppers Pizza: the late-night counter one block over
Volume One's page, last updated in March 2024, describes creative pizzas with toppings from buffalo chicken to mac 'n' cheese and cheese-coated appetizers with over a dozen dipping sauces. The Toppers site calls Topperstix its signature item and also lists wings, baked mac 'n' cheese and vegan options.
Wikipedia says Scott Gittrich founded Toppers in 1991 in Champaign, Illinois, opened the first Whitewater, Wisconsin store in 1993 and sold the first franchise in Eau Claire in 1997. It describes a college-town model with most stores open until 3 AM or later, which suits a town where Wikipedia counts nearly 7,000 UW-Stout students.
A September 2026 reviewer called it way better than Domino's. A 2024 reviewer liked the thin crust, thought it a little too crisp, noted cheese and veggie pizzas but no halal options and valued that the kitchen was open late. The caveat is delivery: a June 2026 reviewer said carryout is always good but delivery is hit or miss, with a pepperonistix order that arrived mostly bread and without the sauces requested, and a July 2026 reviewer found the wings barely sauced. The Toppers page promises delivery in about 25 minutes, which is the chain's own claim, so carryout looks like the safer bet.
The closest hotel to the counter is the Cobblestone Inn & Suites at UW Stout, about 0.16 miles away.
Lucette Brewing: wood-fired pizza on Hudson Road
Volume One's 2023 Best of roundup named Lucette the best restaurant in Menomonie and recommended the Sweet Honey Love, which the site describes with pepperoni, hand-pulled mozzarella, red pepper flakes, oregano and a honey drizzle. Visit Eau Claire's day-trip page calls Lucette known for highly raved-about pizzas paired with craft beers, ciders or wines.
The hours matter here: the site lists 4:30 PM to 9 PM Monday to Thursday and 11:30 AM to 9 PM Friday to Sunday, and Google's hours match, so a Monday to Thursday lunch will not work. Reviewers name The Kenyon, which the current site menu does not list, a reminder that the menu rotates.
A June 2026 reviewer found a huge parking lot with spaces marked by empty kegs, a dining room that could seat about 100 and a Wednesday night after 7 PM so full they got the last table. A July 2026 visitor advised using both hands because the slices are thin and the toppings slide, and suggested skipping the Lemony Stickens starter if pizza is coming, since the bread tastes much like the crust. A June 2026 reviewer loved a pickle pizza with some kick, and a May 2026 reviewer thought the pizza good though carrying a lot of char.
Lucette takes its name from Paul Bunyan's sweetheart and Travel Wisconsin dates the brewery to 2010. Anyone curious about the brewery behind the pizza can read the full Lucette Brewing story, from the lumber-era name to the event pavilion.
Pizza Hut on Highway 25: the dine-in chain
The chain began in Wichita, Kansas, on 31 May 1958, when brothers Dan and Frank Carney opened a single restaurant. The Menomonie page lists hours of 10:30 AM to 10 PM, rising to 11 PM on Friday and Saturday, and notes that delivery hours may vary.
A March 2026 reviewer who dined in with a granddaughter enjoyed crispy thin crust, a fresh dinner salad and a short wait, and took home enough leftovers for two more meals. A July 2025 reviewer found a quiet weekday dining room and pizza that tastes the same as at any Pizza Hut. Delivery draws the sharpest complaints, since a July 2026 reviewer said an order arrived cold and was left on a hotel hallway floor without a knock, and a December 2024 reviewer found a pizza thinner than expected.
The restaurant sits about 0.22 miles from the Menomonie 7 Theatre and about 0.43 miles from the Hampton Inn & Suites, which makes it the pizza of the Highway 25 and Stout Street side of town.
Travelers choosing among Menomonie's places to stay will find the downtown rooms nearer to Ted's and Toppers.
How to choose
Pick Ted's for a sit-down meal with Greek touches, since the gyro meat, the tzatziki and the family history set it apart, and phone ahead on a Monday. Pick Toppers for carryout, a late night or a quick slice of the chain's oddball toppings. Pick Lucette when the pizza is the main event and a beer is the second, and plan for dinner Monday to Thursday. Pick Pizza Hut for a booth with a children's menu on the highway side of town.
For a bigger party, Google marks Ted's and Toppers as good for groups and Pizza Hut as taking reservations. A slice is one stop in a day or an evening out in Menomonie, which can add a show at the Mabel Tainter and a walk by the Red Cedar trailhead beside Lucette.
What this guide leaves out
Prices and specials change, so this guide gives none, and the hours here come from each kitchen's own page or from Google and deserve a quick check. Volume One also lists a Papa Murphy's Take 'n' Bake at 2321 State Highway 25 North on a page last updated in February 2024, and Visit Eau Claire says Stout Craft Co. has pizzas on its menu, but this guide does not cover either and could not confirm Papa Murphy's current status.
Diners who want something other than pizza can weigh the wider field of other Menomonie restaurants, from downtown to the highway strip.
Two kitchens 0.06 miles apart on Main Street East still sum up the choice: a family parlor that has fed the town since 1970 and a counter that stays lit until 3 AM.
Frequently asked questions
Published September 28, 2026
















