The Tainter family, the sandstone building, the 1890 organ, the Spirit Room, tours and access, from the theater's pages, historians and reviewers.
A cube of rock-faced gray sandstone with a cone-topped tower at each corner stands at 205 Main Street East, built by a lumberman for the daughter he lost. That is the Mabel Tainter Theater Menomonie visitors can still tour, which Andrew Tainter gave to the city on July 3, 1890, and which still holds a pipe organ built in 1890.
This guide goes into the family, the stonework, the organ, the restorations, the tours and access, and it gives no ticket prices, because the theater's pages carry none for shows. Some numbers differ from source to source, including the seat count and the organ's pipe count, and where they do the guide says so rather than choosing one.
Sponsored
The Tainters and the lumber money behind the building
Captain Andrew Tainter and his wife Bertha paid for the Mabel Tainter after their daughter Mabel died in 1886 at 19. Tainter was born in 1823, settled in Menomonie in 1846 and became a partner in the lumber firm that grew into Knapp, Stout and Co., which the Wisconsin Historical Society says eventually became one of the largest lumber producers in the Mississippi Valley. The 1973 National Register nomination describes him as both a ruthless industrialist and a generous philanthropist.
The Wisconsin Historical Society credits a Unitarian minister, Henry Doty Maxson, with inspiring the Tainters to build a center for the city's moral and social welfare. The building began as more than a theater, with a reading room and library, club rooms and an auditorium, and it was the original home of the Menomonie Unitarian Society. The Dunn County Historical Society adds that the lower level held a community room, a women's sewing parlor, a young men's club room and a billiards room.
Construction began in April 1889, and the building was dedicated on July 3, 1890. The library opened in January 1891, and the public library moved to a new building in 1986, leaving the old reading room as the box office and gallery store. A 2011 Volume One article noted that the reading room also served as a Laura Ingalls Wilder Historic Highway information site.
Captain Tainter paid the operating costs until his death in 1899 and then set up an endowment that Wikipedia puts at $65,000, grown to $105,000 by 1925. The Dunn County Historical Society quotes the family's stated aim as "to accomplish that which would be of permanent value to the citizens of Menomonie".
Sandstone, towers and Moorish curves: the architecture
It is a Richardsonian Romanesque building of local Dunnville sandstone, and the Wisconsin Historical Society says the auditorium shows a Moorish influence. The Wisconsin Historical Society's property record describes a two-story, hipped-roof, cube-shaped building with massive cone-topped corner towers and a low entry arch whose spandrels carry the building date. The nomination adds a boat prow on the entrance platform, which it says honors Tainter's start as a steamboat pilot.
The Dunn County Historical Society says local and imported Scottish stonemasons worked on the stone for about a year. Sources differ on who drew it: the National Register record and the Wisconsin Historical Society name Harvey Ellis, who worked for the Buffington firm, while Wikipedia notes that some sources dispute that and credit Edgar Eugene Joralemon.
The Mabel's history page lists hand-stenciled walls and ceilings, marble stairs and floors, leaded stained glass, walnut and oak woodwork, brass fixtures and four fireplaces, each built with a different stone or technique. A reviewer in February 2026 wrote that it is worth the trip just to see the beauty and detail of the building. An undated Portal Wisconsin profile says the old library has a mahogany table with a round furnace at its center.
The Steere and Turner organ
The Mabel Tainter's pipe organ is an 1890 tracker built by Steere and Turner, and it is still in the building. The Pipe Organ Database lists it as Opus 300, with two manuals and pedal and mechanical key action. Its console sits in the Tainter's box on stage right, with the pipes in a chamber on the second floor above it.
The Mabel's history page says the organ was water-powered at first and later converted to electric, and the Pipe Organ Database says parts of the original water-powered blowing engine remain in the basement. A 2011 Volume One article put the organ's 1890 cost at $4,160.
The theater's history page gives 1,597 pipes and 28 stops, from 2 inches to 16 feet, but the Pipe Organ Database counts 29 ranks, 32 stops and 1,353 pipes, and the 1973 nomination says 1,550 pipes, so treat any pipe count as approximate. The history page says restoration of the organ began in 1957 and that work toward another restoration was under way in 2025. The database notes the organ was in good condition as of December 2020, in a note dated April 13, 2022.
If hearing the organ is the reason for the trip, ask the box office at 715-235-0001 whether a given event features it.
Restorations from 2007 to 2024, and the Spirit Room
The Mabel has been restored more than once, most visibly in a 2007 renovation and addition and a new front staircase finished in 2024. The 2007 project, by the firm Miller Dunwiddie, added fire and life-safety work, accessibility updates and modernized building systems. Portal Wisconsin's undated profile says the addition uses sandstone from the original quarry, with annex stone four inches thick against 16 to 24 inches in the original walls.
Portal Wisconsin also says the society that runs the building received the 2008 Historic Restoration Award from the Wisconsin Historical Society. Conrad Schmitt Studios, which did the decorative painting, says the restoration won one of four 2010 AIA Minneapolis Merit Awards. The same Portal Wisconsin profile lists a 1950s plan to convert the building into city offices among the setbacks it survived, alongside the decline of vaudeville in the early 1930s and the library's relocation.
In July 2024 the theater cut the ribbon on a new front staircase built to match the historic design, after raising $275,000 over five years to replace stone stairs that were 134 years old, WEAU reported. The theater's executive director, Lucas Chase, told WEAU that "People love coming in this side, it's the historic entrance". That report said the lower-level historic bathrooms had been closed for over five years because of water damage, with plans to refinish them, so ask the box office whether they have reopened.
Downstairs, the Spirit Room was once a youth center, later used mostly for storage, meetings and offices, and is now a lounge that uses historic colors, fixtures and stenciling. The site lists it open Thursday from 4:30 to 10 p.m., Friday and Saturday from 4:30 p.m. to midnight and on show nights, with an entrance on 2nd Street or through the north annex. A reviewer in March 2026 liked it for intermission and for hanging out before and after the show, and a reviewer in November 2025 mentions free music and trivia there.
Touring the Mabel Tainter
Guided historic tours run Fridays and Saturdays from noon to 3 p.m., the site says, with the last tour leaving at 2:30 p.m. and no reservation required for general public tours. The page's summary line says Thursday to Saturday while its body and sidebar say Friday and Saturday, so call the box office at 715-235-0001 to confirm the day. It also says tours can change or be canceled for private events, scheduled shows or unforeseen circumstances.
Ghost tours, which the site describes as covering the supernatural and spookier side of the Mabel's history, are scheduled by calling the box office. Tour length and cost are not on that page, so ask when you call. A 2020 Volume One article described docent-led tours with a strongly encouraged $5 donation, and a 2024 Community Foundation of Dunn County page called the tours free, so treat any amount as unconfirmed.
A reviewer in November 2025 took a tour to learn the history of the Tainter family and called the staff and volunteers helpful, knowledgeable and friendly. The 2011 Volume One article reported that visitors who asked the caretakers could go on the stage, which may or may not still be offered. The foundation page adds that tours are also offered at other times by appointment, and the site asks large or private groups to email to schedule.
Seeing a show: seats, sightlines and getting in
A reviewer in March 2026 praised it as a very cozy small-venue theater with great sightlines. A May 2026 reviewer came for Fiddler on the Roof and was impressed by the quality of the production, and a 2020 reviewer who came for a Buddy Holly reunion show with teenage sons found the setting intimate and the acoustics great.
Seat counts vary by source, with the site's tours page saying 269 seats, its history page 261, and Wikipedia and the state property record 313, so none is safe to quote. Portal Wisconsin's profile gives the stage as 24 by 20 feet.
The site lists Guys on Ice, an ice-fishing comedy, on November 5, 2026, and Pinery Boys and TrueGrass Bluegrass on November 14, 2026, each with a 7:30 p.m. start. It also lists the Holiday Artisan Market on November 20 and 21, 2026, starting at noon.
The site says the Mabel is fully accessible and asks guests to use the North Annex entrance, which opens one hour before performances, with will-call tickets at both entrances. Google lists a wheelchair accessible entrance, parking, restroom and seating along with a good-for-children tag, and Travel Wisconsin lists accessible parking and an elevator. The Main Street staircase is the historic entrance, in the executive director's words in 2024, while the site points guests to the north annex.
The Menomonie Theater Guild, which residents founded in 1958 partly to help preserve the Mabel Tainter, rents the theater for productions, and an undated Madstage listing says that comes to at least three a season.
Weighing the Mabel against the Guild and the cinema on Highway 25 is easier with the three set side by side in theaters in Menomonie.
Planning a visit around the Mabel Tainter
The building stands on Main Street across from UW-Stout. The Cobblestone Inn and Suites on Main Street East is less than 0.1 miles away, and the wider choice of rooms is weighed in hotels in Menomonie.
For a beer afterward, Lucette Brewing Company on Hudson Road is about 0.6 miles from the Mabel Tainter. Dinner before curtain can come from the choices in restaurants in Menomonie.
The rest of a day around the building, from the lake to the trail, belongs under things to do in Menomonie. Walk up to the sandstone cube on Main Street East and it is easy to see what the family built: a memorial to a young woman who loved music and the arts, with a stage and a Spirit Room lounge that the site lists as open on show nights.
Frequently asked questions
Published August 31, 2026












