An arcade bar, a long-running tavern, a songwriters' lounge and an east side dive, and which one fits your night.
The best seat in a Sturgeon Bay bar depends on whether you want to play something, say something or simply sit with a cheap drink and a stranger's stories. The Sturgeon Bay bars worth a night are a small, mixed set, and most of them sit within a few minutes' walk of one another on the downtown side of the bay.
This is not a town of rooftop cocktail lists. It is a town of a bowling alley with pinball, a long-running local tavern, a lounge for songwriters that does not serve alcohol, and a neighborhood dive on the east side. The three downtown stops are within about 0.2 miles of each other, so the choice is about mood, not distance.
Sponsored
Downtown: play, drink cheap, or listen
Check hours before you walk over. The bar's own site lists summer operating hours of 4 p.m. to 2 a.m. Monday to Thursday, noon to 2:30 a.m. on Friday and Saturday, and noon to 2 a.m. on Sunday, and says it opens year-round with modified hours on most holidays. Bowling prices are not posted, so ask at the bar. The bar's site also announced lofts above the building in May 2026 and tells the story of a sailboat street-art piece out front, so the building is easy to spot.
One practical note: the bar has no website of its own that turned up in research, so the phone, 920-366-1777, is the way to confirm anything.
All three downtown stops are close: Butch's is about 0.1 miles from Cherry Lanes, and the lounge about 0.2 miles. A night could run bowling, then a cheap beer, then a Thursday song or two, though the late closing at the first two does not line up with the lounge's earlier hours.
The east side: a neighborhood dive
After dinner, and the bars inside restaurants
Some of the best bar stools in town are in dining rooms. If the evening starts with dinner at one of the restaurants in Sturgeon Bay, a drink at the bar is easy to add.
The Nightingale Supper Club sits about 1.4 miles north-east on Egg Harbor Road, and reviewers say they ordered an Old Fashioned at its bar while waiting for a table.
The Mill Supper Club is about 3.1 miles north on Highway 42/57 and has a dark wood bar. Its own site lists a happy hour on Thursday and Friday from 4 to 5 p.m., in the bar only.
Back downtown, a 30-seat bar came with the 2018 makeover of the Cedar Crossing inn, and one guest praised the bartender and a Moscow mule.
A bourbon bar that has changed
If you read that Red Oak Winery and Bourbon Bar is a bourbon stop, check first. The winery began in downtown Sturgeon Bay in 2004 and later moved to 5781 Highway 42 in Carlsville, about 8.2 miles north of Cherry Lanes. County and state tourism directories still carry the address, but Google lists it as permanently closed and its own site was blocked to us, so treat it as closed unless the owners tell you otherwise. If you want bourbon, ask the bartenders in town; none of the bars above makes it a feature.
What to know before you go
Wisconsin bars and restaurants may not serve liquor after 2 a.m. Monday to Friday or 2:30 a.m. on Saturday and Sunday. Sundays are the hard day: Butch's is closed and Dutch's hours are unclear, while Cherry Lanes opens at noon. Daytime plans are easier to find among the daytime sights around Sturgeon Bay before the bars open.
None of these places promises a big night. They offer something smaller and more useful, a pinball machine, a cheap beer and a bartender with local history to share, and that is usually enough to turn a quiet Sturgeon Bay evening into a story to tell.
Frequently asked questions
Published November 2, 2026



















