Beloit Restaurants: Supper Clubs, Pizza, 4:30 am Bakery

Two Wisconsin supper clubs, a downtown Italian dinner, Fourth Street pizza and breakfast, and a family bakery that opens at 4:30 am.

The Beloit restaurants worth knowing keep a clock that is Wisconsin through and through: doors open at 4:30 am at a family bakery, supper clubs that fill up for the Friday fish fry, and a Fourth Street pizza counter that Google lists as open until 2 am on weeknights.

Eating your way through restaurants in Beloit, Wisconsin, starts with the two supper clubs, moves downtown for dinner and a drink, walks Fourth Street from breakfast to pizza, and ends where the day begins, at the bakery.

Sponsored

Hours drift, so treat every time below as a starting point and call ahead.

Supper clubs: Benedetti's and the Butterfly Club

Beloit has two supper clubs worth the drive, one on South Riverside Drive north of downtown and one out on County Road X to the east.

A supper club is a Wisconsin dining room that works like a living room: a long bar for waiting, a Friday fish fry, and a brandy old fashioned made sweet with a splash of soda.

Benedetti's Supper Club opened in 1945 on South Riverside Drive, about 4 miles north of downtown, and ran as a family business until Jayme Braatz bought it in December 2024, the first owner from outside the Benedetti family.

Tosca Benedetti wrote the original recipes, and the Beloit Daily News reported that some items are still made exactly her way.

The restaurant describes baked cod, a Friday fish fry, house-made lasagna and a soup and salad bar, with ice cream grasshoppers at the bar.

Travel Wisconsin adds that the ice cream drinks are big enough that servers bring extra spoons, and that you can add your name with the hostess and wait in the lounge over a brandy old fashioned.

Google lists dinner service Wednesday through Saturday from mid-afternoon, with the kitchen closed Sunday through Tuesday (call to confirm).

One visitor flew in from Florida and asked a sister to find a supper club for a fish fry, then wrote that the place "didn't disappoint".

Another reviewer found the bar dark and busy and said a baked fish arrived undercooked, so a busy Friday may test your patience.

The Butterfly Club began in 1924 as the Butterfly Tea Room, built by Hal and Mae Sherburne on five acres in the Town of Turtle and named for the yellow and white butterflies in the field next door.

A fire destroyed it on December 18, 1972, and it was rebuilt on the same site eleven months later.

The Sala brothers, Mike and Hektor, both chefs, have run it since 1999, and the Butterfly Club sits about 5.5 miles east of downtown at 5246 East County Road X.

The Gazette reported in June 2026 that hostess Joy King has worked there since 1962 and that Mike Williamson has played the lounge since the 1970s.

The Beloit Daily News names the fish fry, slow-roasted prime rib and shrimp de jonghe among its specialties, and the club's site lists live music on Friday and Saturday evenings.

Its site suggests reservations, and one reviewer says Fridays take none, so call before you drive out.

One longtime local reviewer called it their favorite of the three supper clubs in the area.

A more critical review praised the room but said the steak and lobster came under-seasoned.

Visit Beloit's dining page also lists the 615 Club as a supper club operating since 1936; confirm it is open before you plan around it.

Downtown dinner at Velvet Buffalo

For a sit-down dinner downtown, start with Velvet Buffalo Modern Italian on Public Avenue.

Velvet Buffalo sits inside the Hotel Goodwin, at 500 Public Avenue, in a building constructed in 1923 that housed offices until the mid-2000s.

Its own site describes a bar social hour from 3 to 4:30 pm with craft cocktails, wines and small plates, and the full dinner menu from 4:30.

A 2018 Beloit Daily News report described the hotel and its café as new downtown projects planned around local ingredients.

If you are staying overnight, the restaurant is inside the Hotel Goodwin itself, so the walk back to your room is short.

A reviewer staying for work wrote that the staff handled a food allergy carefully and offered substitutions, and the restaurant says it accommodates dietary substitutions.

Reviewers mention the focaccia and a complimentary glass of prosecco on arrival; one found the sausage pasta a little salty.

Google's price range for Velvet Buffalo runs higher than for the pizza places on Fourth Street, and reservations go through the restaurant's site.

Grand Avenue: pub food, live bands and pool

When the question is where to eat in Beloit after dinner or on a Saturday night, Grand Avenue has the answer in a few blocks.

Grand Avenue Pub has poured on West Grand Avenue since 2014, with a full bar, a floor for dancing, a pool and dart room, and live bands every weekend.

The kitchen sends out burgers, fries and wings, and the taps include Wisconsin craft beer such as Spotted Cow.

A musician who reviewed it wrote that bands are treated "like royalty", and another visitor, there to catch a local group, praised the bartenders.

Google lists weekend hours running to 2:30 am (call to confirm), which keeps it among the later options in town.

One reviewer who drove 40 minutes with a gift card found the food fine rather than exceptional, and was told parties under four are not taken as reservations.

About 0.4 miles east, the Carom Room offers Diamond pool tables, a carom table, darts and a full bar with food.

Reviewers like the room and the staff, but one thought the prices high, paying $24 for three games of pool for two.

Fourth Street: Jerry's Cafe, Tilley's and Palermo's

Three everyday restaurants sit within about half a mile of each other on Fourth Street, one for breakfast, two for pizza.

Jerry's Cafe serves breakfast and lunch every day at 935 Fourth Street, and it is Mexican-American in the way the menu reads: huevos rancheros, grits and eggs, omelets under green sauce, and breakfast burritos.

The kitchen makes its own salsas, and the list also runs to raspberry cheesecake stuffed French toast, strawberry pancakes and fresh strawberry orange juice.

Google shows an early start, with doors opening at 6 am and the kitchen finishing by 2:30 pm (2 pm on Sunday), so this is a morning stop (call to confirm).

Reviewers keep coming back to the portions, the green sauce and the Door County melt; one visitor ate there three days running.

Opinions are not unanimous: one reviewer called the dining room a little dated and another thought the chilaquiles came out more like soup.

Tilley's Pizza House, at 900 Fourth Street, has been family owned since the 1950s, and a 2019 Gazette review said it claims to be the first and oldest pizza restaurant in Beloit.

The Greater Beloit Chamber of Commerce lists it as serving the area since 1955, and the original location, per the Gazette, is now Kline's Club 88.

The thin crust is cracker-like, the Gazette wrote, and thick and gluten-free crusts are on the menu.

It shares its building with the Ballyhoo Tavern.

A reviewer who grew up in Beloit says Tilley's was always their favorite pizza, and another recommends the Kitchen Sink pizza with a bucket of small beers.

Google lists it open daily from 11 am, with later closing on Friday and Saturday (call to confirm); online ordering runs through its own site.

Palermo's Pizza, at 618 Fourth Street, is the late option: it says it has served pizza, pastas, salads and burgers since 1968, and Google shows it open until 2 am on weeknights (call to confirm).

Reviews of Palermo's are mixed: one describes missing items on a late carry-out order and another mentions new owners, so order with patience.

Old Fashion Bakery on Park Avenue

For donuts and bread, Old Fashion Bakery at 1255 Park Avenue is the stop, about 0.9 miles northeast of downtown.

The bakery's site dates it to 1932, and the Beloit Daily News traces the Old Fashioned Bake Shop name to 1933.

Ron and Cindy Ross bought it in December 2024 and their daughter Ashley Thom runs it; she told the paper the recipes are not changing.

Retail is a little under half of sales, with wholesale, mostly to Woodman's, making up the rest.

The bakery's site lists weekday hours from 4:30 am to 5 pm, Sunday hours from 6 am to 1 pm, and a closed Saturday.

Reviewers praise the powdered donut holes, cinnamon rolls and oatmeal cream pies, and one wished for a wider selection, so go early if you want a full box.

The 90th-anniversary coverage in the Gazette called the holiday shortbread cookies dipped in white chocolate a local favorite.

Planning a day of eating in Beloit

Plan around the closed days: both supper clubs close on Monday, Benedetti's also closes Sunday and Tuesday, and the bakery is closed Saturday (call to confirm).

A day could run bakery, Jerry's, a walk along Riverside Park, then dinner downtown or out at a supper club; the parks of Beloit make the stretch between meals easy.

For what else fills the hours between meals, start with the things to do in Beloit.

Come at either end of the day, from a 4:30 am bakery door to a 2 am pizza counter, and the town fits the clock it opened with.

Frequently asked questions

Published September 28, 2026

You might also like

See all