Bakeries in Beloit, from Park Avenue Donuts to Pan Dulce

Old Fashion Bakery's Park Avenue donuts, Fourth Street pan dulce, an east-side counter on Prairie Avenue, and the Saturday market.

The best bakeries in Beloit keep odd hours: one opens its doors at 4:30 in the morning, another stays lit until 9 at night, and the Saturday option is not a shop at all.

Three bakeries anchor the town, a Park Avenue donut counter that dates to the 1930s, a Mexican panadería on Fourth Street, and a Prairie Avenue shop on the east side that bakes everything from raspberry danishes to tamales.

Sponsored

This is the route through them, with what each one does well, what reviewers say went wrong, and where to eat once the box is in the car. For a sit-down meal afterward, the restaurants of Beloit run from supper clubs to Fourth Street pizza.

Old Fashion Bakery: the Park Avenue anchor

Old Fashion Bakery, at 1255 Park Avenue, is the answer if you came for donuts, and it is about 0.9 miles north-northeast of downtown.

The bakery's own site dates it to 1932, and the Beloit Daily News traces the story to the Depression, when Clem Schroeder's mother baked coffee cakes and bread rolls in the family kitchen and his father sold them with a partner.

Clem Schroeder took over in January 1933, and that March Earl McMaster bought out that partner, which is when the business became the Old Fashioned Bake Shop.

Schroeder and his wife, Mary, ran it until 1972, when Dennis and Rose Mulcahy bought it on November 13 of that year with money Dennis borrowed from his father.

Dennis Mulcahy told the paper the shop's attitude is that "the customer has to matter."

The Mulcahys sold in December 2024 to the Ross family of Janesville, the first change of ownership since the Nixon era.

As of early 2025 the Beloit Daily News reported that Ron and Cindy Ross own it and their daughter Ashley Thom runs it, and her message to regulars was blunt: "We are not changing the recipes."

That matters because this is a bigger operation than the storefront suggests.

As of early 2025 the Beloit Daily News reported that the building is 7,100 square feet with 22 full-time employees, and a little over half of sales are wholesale, mostly to Woodman's Markets, so the donut holes in a Janesville grocery cart may have started here.

One reviewer wrote that they bought the powdered donut holes at a Woodman's all the way over in Eau Claire and that they were still moist, which they took as a sign of handmade rather than mass-produced.

What to order and when to go

Start with the case that reviewers describe: powdered donut holes, cinnamon rolls, cupcakes and oatmeal cream pies.

One traveler wrote that they stop every time they drive from Chicago to Madison and called the oatmeal cream pie the best they have had.

Around the holidays the bakery is known for a shortbread cookie dipped in white chocolate and topped with sprinkles, and the Beloit Daily News reported in 2023 that it sells in the thousands each season.

The bakery also runs a deli counter with sandwiches, so a box of rolls and lunch can be one stop.

The bakery's site lists Monday through Friday from 4:30 am to 5 pm, Sunday from 6 am to 1 pm, and Saturday closed (confirm before a weekend trip).

The bakery's site shows pickup through DoorDash, and for custom orders it is best to call the bakery.

One reviewer called the selection okay and wished for more choices.

Another reviewer praised the staff and the low prices and mentioned a $4.99 deal through a food-rescue app.

Fourth Street: Jerry's Bakery and Jerry's Cafe

Jerry's Bakery at 933 Fourth Street is the pan dulce stop, about 0.6 miles north-northwest of downtown and open daily from 6 am to 9 pm.

The shop describes traditional Mexican breads, artisanal pan dulce and custom cakes for weddings and birthdays.

The Beloit Daily News reported in October 2024 that Margarito and Evelia Jaimes had run the bakery for nearly 10 years, and that Evelia's brother owns the cafe next door.

One reviewer called the tres leches cakes moist and the pastries, many filled with fruit such as pineapple, a quick breakfast, and a 2017 review said the average item cost under a dollar.

Cakes draw split reviews.

One customer said the cake looked just like their picture and another said their wedding cake turned out better than imagined, while another couple never heard back after texting pictures and went elsewhere, so confirm your order in writing and early.

Next door sits the family-run Jerry's Cafe, a Mexican-American breakfast and lunch counter that serves from 6 am to 2:30 pm (2 pm on Sunday).

Reviewers keep recommending the green sauce over the omelet, the Door County melt and the strawberry orange juice.

Order a pastry from the bakery for the road and a plate from the cafe to sit down with; one reviewer there thought the dining room a little dated but the welcome warm.

Danny's Donuts & Bakery on the east side

Danny's Donuts & Bakery, at 2627 Prairie Avenue, is the one that rewards a drive, about 3.1 miles north-northeast of downtown and 2.2 miles from Old Fashion Bakery.

The shop describes daily donuts, cookies, dinner rolls and pastries such as raspberry danishes, plus tamales, churros, and custom decorated cakes and cupcakes.

Google shows it open daily from 7 am to 6 pm (confirm before you go).

A visitor who stopped at random on a drive wrote that it was a lovely place for a donut and cookies, and that the raspberry danish was delicious enough to bring them back for bread.

Another reviewer called the donuts always moist, and a third praised the dinner rolls.

The complaints are specific: one buyer found the tamales scrambled, and a wedding order arrived hours late with plain cake and stale churros, so treat Danny's as a counter you visit rather than a caterer you hire for a big day.

The Travel Wisconsin page lists it for donuts and other pastries and gives the phone number as 608-207-9890.

Saturday in Beloit: the farmers' market and Mr B's

Old Fashion Bakery is closed on Saturday, so the Saturday plan runs through downtown.

The Beloit Farmers' Market began in 1975 in the Super Block near where City Hall now stands, with about a dozen sellers, and by its 50th season in 2025 it ran to about 150 vendors at full capacity.

Travel Wisconsin listed the 2026 season as May 2 to October 31, Saturdays from 8 am to 1 pm along Grand Avenue and State Street, and it calls it the second-largest farmers' market in Wisconsin.

Reviewers mention honey, artisanal cheeses, flowers, street food, live music and roasted cashews, and one advises bringing cash.

Last winter the market ran Saturdays 9 am to noon through April at 557 East Grand Avenue (confirm this year's dates).

For a hot breakfast a short walk from the market, Mr B's Coffee & Snack at 315 Short Street is about 0.15 miles from the market, a diner serving breakfast and lunch.

Visitors pin dollar bills to the walls, one reviewer's kids were excited to hang theirs, and a 2025 review described a home-brewed coffee and homemade breakfast for about $5 (a price from that visit).

Google shows it closed Wednesday and Thursday and opens at 10:30 am on Sunday (confirm hours).

A bakery route through Beloit

A weekday works best: Old Fashion Bakery when the doors open at 4:30 for rolls and donut holes, Jerry's Bakery for pan dulce mid-morning, and Danny's on the way out toward the east side.

Sunday works too, though Old Fashion Bakery closes at 1 pm and Jerry's Cafe at 2.

Between stops, the day fills up from the riverfront to the ballpark with picks from the Beloit things-to-do roundup.

Whichever order you choose, the town's baking runs from a 4:30 am oven to a 9 pm pastry case, and the box you carry out is the proof.

Frequently asked questions

Published October 12, 2026

You might also like

See all