Pizza in Beloit (Cracker Crust, Stuffed Pies, Pickle Pizza)

Four independent pizza places in Beloit, from a Fourth Street house that claims to be the oldest to a north-side kitchen that tops a pie with pickles.

Choosing pizza in Beloit comes down to a map line more than a menu line.

Fourth Street holds the old guard: a thin-crust pizza house that calls itself the city's first, and a late-night counter that Google lists as open until 2 am most nights.

Sponsored

Up on the north side, two kitchens within about 0.1 mile of each other turn out stuffed pies, calzones and a pizza topped with pickles.

This guide covers those four independents, what each is like, and where each one falls short. Chain pizza is left out on purpose.

What a Beloit pizza usually looks like

Tavern-style pizza, thin and cut in squares, is common across the Midwest, and Tilley's cuts its pies that way.

Milwaukee's version pushes the crust thinner still, to a cracker, and Milwaukee Magazine reports that the style is credited to a Third Ward restaurant that opened in 1945.

Tilley's, the oldest pizza house in town by its own account, cuts its pies in squares too.

Not every pizzeria here follows the pattern: one north-side kitchen sells stuffed pizza and another serves a pie built around pickles, so decide what you want before you pick a side of town.

Fourth Street: Tilley's and Palermo's

Tilley's Pizza House and Palermo's Pizza are about 0.36 mile apart on Fourth Street, and they are the two to compare if you want the classic version.

Tilley's Pizza House at 900 Fourth Street has been family owned since the 1950s and claims to be the first and oldest pizza restaurant in Beloit.

That review described a crust "much like a cracker", a house-made sauce with an earthy tomato taste, and a pie cut in squares, with comfortable booths along the windows.

The 2019 review listed thin, thick or gluten-free crusts and said the original location had become Kline's Club 88 on Portland Avenue.

The Ballyhoo Tavern shares the building, and the entrance splits between the two rooms.

Google lists Tilley's as open daily from 11 am, closing at 10 pm Monday through Thursday, 11 pm on Friday and Saturday, and 9 pm on Sunday (call to confirm), with beer and wine, outdoor seating, and free lot and street parking.

One reviewer recommends the Kitchen Sink pizza with a bucket of small beers, and online ordering runs through ChowNow on its own site.

Service is not flawless: an August 2026 review complains that a burger came out well done and one child's pizza arrived long after the sandwiches, so order pizza here rather than a burger.

Google gives Tilley's 4.4 stars across 1,567 reviews.

Palermo's Pizza at 618 Fourth Street is the late option, and Google's summary describes it as a casual space since 1968.

Google lists it open from 2 pm to 2 am Monday through Saturday and until midnight on Sunday (call to confirm), with a free parking lot and free street parking.

Pizza shares the menu with pastas, salads, fried food and burgers, and reviewers also mention calzones, wings and burritos.

Treat Palermo's as a late-night carryout stop rather than a destination.

Google shows a 3.4 rating across 344 reviews, against 4.4 for Tilley's, and the recent reviews in the set describe wrong or missing items on late orders, soggy takeout and a slow refund process.

One reviewer says the kitchen changed hands and the food has slipped, while a longtime customer calls it one of their favorite places locally even after a disappointing calzone order.

Google lists it as not taking reservations and not serving beer or wine, with prices in the $10 to $20 range.

The north side: Juanito's and Prime Time

Juanito's Pizza and Prime Time Pizza sit on Harrison Avenue and Park Avenue, about 1.2 miles north-northeast of Tilley's, and they answer the question of what to order when thin and cracker is not the plan.

Juanito's Pizza at 1802 Harrison Avenue shares a building with Dogworld.

Its own menu lists a Pickle Lover's pizza built on pickle, garlic, ranch and mozzarella, along with a stuffed pizza, calzones, subs, pasta and desserts.

The kitchen also makes chorizo pies drizzled with salsa verde, cheese-stuffed breadsticks, fried pickle spears and cinnamon sticks finished with icing.

Reviewers keep praising the crust, which several describe as light and soft, and the size of the calzones and stuffed pies; one said a single stuffed slice filled them up.

A family who visited on Father's Day wrote that the server offered to cut slices small for their four-year-old, and Google lists the room as good for children and groups.

Google lists weekday hours from 3 pm to 11 pm Monday through Thursday, 11 am to midnight on Friday and Saturday, and 11 am to 10 pm on Sunday (call to confirm), and the restaurant offers delivery and pickup through Slice.

Juanito's holds a 4.2 on Google across 150 reviews, the smallest sample of the four, so one bad night moves the number.

Prime Time Pizza at 1765 Park Avenue makes thin-crust pizzas with sausage, mushroom, pepperoni, hamburger and ham, plus stuffed calzones, chicken wings and fries, and it is closed on Tuesdays.

Google lists it open from 3 pm on Monday and 11 am the rest of the week, closing at 10:45 pm Monday, Wednesday and Thursday, 11:45 pm on Friday and Saturday, and 9:45 pm on Sunday (call to confirm).

It reads as a carryout and delivery kitchen: Google does not list dine-in service and lists no restroom.

One reviewer wrote that an order came out in 20 minutes during a Bears and Packers game, when other pizza places were likely taking 45 or more, and that the calzone fed two people with leftovers.

The counterpoint is a May 2026 review describing a burnt calzone and cold mushrooms on a nearly $70 order, so quality can swing from night to night.

Google rates it 4.0 across 542 reviews.

When pizza is only part of the plan

For breakfast steps from Tilley's, Jerry's Cafe serves breakfast and lunch every day in a Mexican-American style, and Google lists it closing at 2:30 pm (2 pm on Sunday), so it hands the street over to the pizza places.

For a sit-down dinner that is not pizza, Velvet Buffalo Modern Italian serves scratch-made Italian dishes and steaks on Public Avenue, about 0.3 mile from Palermo's, with a Google price range of $20 to $60 against $10 to $20 at the pizza places.

For a Friday fish fry instead of pizza, Benedetti's Supper Club, about 4 miles north of Fourth Street, has been serving dinner since 1945 on a Wednesday to Saturday schedule (call to confirm).

Anyone building a whole evening can start from the restaurant picks across Beloit, which sort the supper clubs, breakfast counters and downtown dining.

Between meals, there are hours to fill in the Beloit sightseeing guide.

Honest limits: hours, reservations and mixed reviews

Check the hours before you go: Juanito's and Prime Time open at 3 pm on Monday, Prime Time is closed Tuesday, and Palermo's is the one that stays open past midnight (call to confirm).

Google lists Tilley's, Palermo's and Prime Time as not taking reservations, so expect to put your name in at busy times.

Three of the four have recent reviews from unhappy customers, and Google ratings run from 3.4 to 4.4, so read the latest ones before you commit to a big order.

A fair rule of thumb from the facts above: sit down at Tilley's, order stuffed or pickle at Juanito's, order a calzone to go from Prime Time, and keep Palermo's for the nights when it is late and little else is open.

Pick a side of town and the pie follows: cracker-thin squares on Fourth Street, stuffed pies and pickles up north.

Frequently asked questions

Published October 5, 2026

You might also like

See all