Supper club fare and a salad bar on Lincoln Avenue
We started with drinks at the bar and met Rita. We moved to the dining area where they have a great salad bar. We had Filet mignon cooked medium and medium rare. It was delicious and melted in your your mouth! For dessert we had the Chocolate eclairs! Sooo good!
Overall the food and drinks are great. We were not impressed with the prime rib. Very bland. Maybe the grilled prime rib has more flavor. Other items on the menu have been good. I liked the broadted chicken. Salad bar is really good. Service is good. Only drawback is that for what you get meals can be a bit pricey. Atmosphere is very supper club like.
Not only has Rita added her own touches while preserving the 1961 charm of this gem of a supper club, but she has also carried on the warm, welcoming spirit. Rita is connected with the original owners' family, who have passed down recipes from the broasted chicken to the top secret old fashioned mix. Don't miss it! We slowed down our pace on a lovely October Sunday here with friends starting out at the bar for the game and moving to the dining room for supper. Rita and her son had our table ready, and Debbie took care of us from there. We had THE best cream of chicken soup and spinach salad with warm bacon dressing along with other salad bar classics. For dinner.....Broasted, Broasted, Broasted. Pork chops, chicken, and potatoes. The Sunday baked chicken special was fall off the bone and served with homemade mashed potatoes, gravy and stuffing. An excellent cap to our trip to Twin Rivers, and can't wait to come back!
We visited Rita’s recently and had a very nice meal. For those that live in the Two Rivers area, Rita’s is located in the former Machuts Supper Club building on Hwy 42. The interior looks like it has seen some updating since being Machuts. We were greeted right away and our server was friendly and told us about the specials. The soup and salad bar is plentiful and the entrees were pretty good too. If you are in the area Rita’s is worth a stop in and try it out for yourself.
We’ve visited twice now and both were great experiences. Bar staff is friendly and greeted us quickly each visit. Seated quickly and salad bar is included with each entree and was filled with fresh favorites. Salas bar soups were both a hit! We have tried the breasted chicken (one of the best we’ve had), baked haddock and chicken stir fry. All were great. Great selections of desserts and both visits we were thrilled with every choice. Definitely a wonderful supper club!
Local time · GMT-6
While you're here
Everything local in Two Rivers, all in one place.
Neapolitan-style pies and cheesy garlic dunkers
Downtown Two Rivers sandwich shop serving subs and pizza
Serving unique pizzas and tasty drinks in Brillion
Wood-fired Neapolitan pizzeria, wine bar, deli, and Italian grocery
Serving pancakes, omelettes, and breakfast burritos in Sheboygan
Old-timey railroad-themed eatery for broaster chicken and draft beer
Craft beer, American dishes, and a welcoming patio
Serving milk tea, bubble tea, and custom drinks in Sheboygan
Is this your business?
Reach people across town and nearby with Rita's Supper Club
Claim it free to post events, jobs and updates that show up on town pages, event calendars and local recommendations — and help local and AI search find you.
Claim this listing
