Pop-Start Pizza

Amanda Freeman

a month ago

We stopped in while in town for a family vacation and left wishing we had a Pop-Start pizza near us at home. Do yourselves a favor and try it. This pizza is incredible. Perfect crust. Interesting combinations. Cooked exactly how it should be. We (adults and kids) were all beyond satisfied with our meal. Every bite had us doing a happy dance in our seats. The staff was lovely to chat with. Kind, informative, great recommendations. The entire place, including the cool bathrooms, was spotless. Fun drink options. Convenient location. Fantastic music and theme. 10/10 across the board. We ordered the Pop-peroni, The Spicoli, and The Beastie Boy with a side of cheesy garlic dunkers. Highly, highly recommend all of the above.

Erik Woll

3 months ago

Absolutely excellent pizza! Best thing you will eat in manitowoc county hands down! My family eats pizza, a lot, travels for pizza, has celebrated PI(zza) day ever year for over a decade and this pizza is in the top 10 zzas we've had anywhere.

Arthur Sharkey

5 months ago

By far hands down the best pizza We have had here in Wisconsin. Pop- Start Pizza makes it all from fresh ingredients in front of you. Get some it's delicious 😋😋 priced fair, very nice atmosphere! Thank you all for making our dinner, y'all make it look easy.

Michael Buselli

5 months ago

Everything at Pop-Start Pizza was wonderful. Justin, the owner, was very friendly and took a few minutes to explain to me how they use the highest quality of ingredients here, and he even sources them from Europe when necessary to get only The BEST. That care in what goes into the pizzas is evident when eating it, as this is truly a quality pizza above almost anything one can find in the United States. After my meal, one of Justin's employees came over to check on us and how we liked it. The whole experience was just 5+ stars. When I come back to Two Rivers on my next vacation here, this is a must return-to. Update: I went back to Pop-Start on another trip to Two Rivers recently, and I'm updating my review to 8 stars for Food, 7 stars for Service, and 7 stars Overall. I thought I was going to get a 5 star experience based on my wonderful original visit but my expectations were greatly exceeded. Justin has outdone himself and the quality of the food was at a record high. On this trip I ordered the NY Margarita, the Milk and Honey, and the Salad Fingers. I highly recommend them all. The quality and taste of the NY Margarita greatly exceeded that which you can get from any other "cheese" pizza elsewhere. The Milk and Honey has a perfect blend different of cheeses mixed with a hint of sweetness from the honey. The Salad Fingers are a unique way to enjoy a Caesar salad, and the Pop-Sauce Dressing is amazing! I wish I lived closer to Two Rivers so I can enjoy this place more often!

HaleyGoesLocal

6 months ago

Absolutely beautiful modern pizzeria. Great staff. Changing specialty pizzas that are always a 10/10. We’ve also tried the salad fingers and for something so simple has such big flavor! Can be a little pricy for a large crowd but highly recommend!