Pizza was tasty. The views here are perfect. I loved the pictures on the walls. I was surprised the Arancini had peas inside it. This was a first for me having it.
Chicago-style pies and an on-site game room
Sonny's Italian Kitchen & Pizzeria is a pizzeria and bar in Sturgeon Bay. We serve Chicago-style pies in a casual, family-friendly venue complete with a game room.
Pizza was tasty. The views here are perfect. I loved the pictures on the walls. I was surprised the Arancini had peas inside it. This was a first for me having it.
Weather was great, but when we asked to sit outside, was confused as to why they’d seat people without a view of the bay - isn’t your beautiful location something to tout? Next time we’ll ask to sit on that side. :-) We ordered Detroit style veggie pizza and it arrived fairly quickly. It was good, but even better reheated in the oven. We’ll stop in again on our next trip!
Fantastic 5-star experience from start to finish! The waterfront views right by the bridge and marina are incredible, and the service was warm, attentive, and welcoming. I ordered the Chicken Parmesan, and it was outstanding—packed with delicious flavor, perfectly melted cheese, and served in a very generous portion. Exceptional food, unbeatable scenery, and top-tier hospitality. We will definitely be coming back!
After a long day, we were tired, exhausted, and looking for a quick bite. We actually headed to another restaurant after doing quite a bit of research, only to find it was closed! Luckily, we stumbled upon this place by accident—and sometimes those unplanned stops turn out to be pretty decent. The ambiance was nice, though it was understandably busy because of the long weekend. Despite the crowd, the staff remained friendly and welcoming, which made the experience pleasant. The fries could have used a little more seasoning, and while the rest of the food was okay, it had the feel of pre-made frozen items rather than freshly prepared dishes. The drinks were good and hit the spot after a long day. Overall, it was a convenient stop with good service and a comfortable atmosphere. It may not be a destination meal, but if you're hungry, tired, and need a quick bite, it does the job!
Really enjoy coming to Sonny’s for a solid, no-fuss Italian meal. The menu has a great variety, and everything I’ve tried has been consistently good. The pizza is definitely a standout—fresh, flavorful, and made just right with a great crust. You can tell they don’t cut corners when it comes to quality. The atmosphere is comfortable and welcoming, whether you’re dining in or just stopping by to grab takeout. Staff has always been friendly and attentive, making the whole experience smooth and enjoyable. It’s one of those places you can count on when you’re craving Italian food and want something reliable and satisfying. Definitely a go-to spot when I’m in the mood for pizza or a hearty meal.
Local time · GMT-6

While you're here
Everything local in Sturgeon Bay, all in one place.

Elegant stone-walled dining room overlooking Lake Michigan

Breakfast plates and dog-friendly patio seating

Breakfast plates and local coffee along Highway 42

Old-school Wisconsin supper club serving steakhouse fare

Rustic 19th-century inn with a restaurant and bakery

Freshly baked 16-inch subs, pizzas, and tacos

Mexican dishes and outdoor seating on West Oak Street

All-day breakfast and classic diner plates in Door County
Is this your business?
Reach people across town and nearby with Sonny's Italian Kitchen & Pizzeria
Claim it free to post events and updates that show up on town pages, event calendars and local recommendations — and help local and AI search find you.
Claim this listing