What fills the dealer booths on Pilgrim Road, when to go, and the barn-sale yard and ReStore that round out a day of antiquing.
Pilgrim Antique Mall is much bigger inside than it appears from the street. It sits about 0.4 miles east of Main Street in Germantown, and many dealers share the floor, so the stock runs from sterling jewelry and vintage clothing to vinyl records and housewares.
Germantown has two more secondhand stops within a few miles: a collectibles yard spread over several buildings, and a Habitat for Humanity ReStore for furniture and building materials. This is how to shop all three, and where to eat between them.
Sponsored
What you find at Pilgrim Antique Mall
The mall's own site says it takes a limited amount of consignment, so if you are clearing out a relative's house, call before you load the car.
The listing for the mall singles out sterling jewelry, vintage clothing and vinyl records, so there are small finds you can carry home and bigger pieces too. Furniture is there too, so measure the space at home and bring the numbers with you.
Toys, records and comic books
Collectors of smaller things should not skip it. A July 2024 write-up by Family Destinations Guide listed tin soldiers, classic dolls, classic board games, comic books and sports memorabilia among the stock. The same piece mentioned lamps running from Victorian styles to 1970s lava lamps, along with vintage record players and cookie jars.
It described the aisles as organized into themed sections, which helps on a first visit when the size of the place catches you off guard. Stock in a dealer mall moves, so treat any list like this as a sample of what turns up rather than a promise of what is on the shelf this week.
If you are hunting one thing, such as a Pyrex pattern or a run of comic books, ask at the counter whether a dealer specializes in it before you start on the aisles.
Hours, address and holidays
Pilgrim Antique Mall is at W156N11500 Pilgrim Road, and its phone number is 262-250-0260. Its website lists hours of 10 am to 5 pm Monday to Saturday and noon to 4 pm on Sunday, but the page carries no date, so call to confirm before a long drive.
The same page lists the mall as closed on Thanksgiving, Christmas, New Year's Day, Easter, the Fourth of July and Memorial Day, and asks shoppers to call ahead on Mother's Day and Labor Day. A Sunday visit gives you four hours, so start there if you only have the afternoon.
The site says the mall takes Visa, Mastercard, Discover, personal checks and cash, and offers gift certificates and layaway. Layaway is worth knowing about if you find a dresser on a day trip and need to come back with a truck. The site also describes its parking as plenty.
The mall is just off Main Street, about 0.4 miles east of the Main Street core, so you can park once and walk to lunch.
Country Aire Antiques and its barn sales
Country Aire Antiques is the second antique stop, about 1.3 miles southeast of Pilgrim on Country Aire Drive.
For coffee on the way back, Kaffeehaus is about 0.7 miles south in a restored schoolhouse from around 1874.
Habitat for Humanity ReStore for bigger pieces
The ReStore is the stop for furniture, appliances and building materials, about 2.3 miles southwest of Pilgrim on Commerce Circle.
The store is roomy because it moved into the old Gander Mountain building, a 30,800-square-foot space, after BizTimes reported in November 2018 that its previous shop on Maple Road, about 7,500 square feet, had become too small. It is run by Habitat for Humanity of Washington and Dodge counties, based in West Bend.
Note the Sunday closure if you are planning a weekend loop: Saturday is the only weekend day both Pilgrim and the ReStore are open, so ask Country Aire about its days when you call. The address is W190 N10768 Commerce Circle, phone 262-255-7470.
The ReStore sits next to two of the town's hotels: Best Western Germantown Inn is about 0.1 miles away and Country Inn about 0.4 miles.
That puts it on the way if you are staying at either one, and the town's other two hotels sit at the south edge of the village by County Line Road.
An antiquing loop with lunch
Start at Pilgrim, because three places to eat sit within half a mile of it. Relish Supper Club is about 0.2 miles northwest, with its list of old fashioneds, and it is one of the Milwaukee-area supper clubs.
Bubs Irish Pub is about 0.4 miles west, and reviews on its own site single out the Reuben rolls and the Friday fish fry. For something quick, Robert's Frozen Custard on Mequon Road is about 0.45 miles southwest, with burgers and a custard flavor of the day.
Before you leave town, House of Home Made Sausage is about half a mile southeast, an old-school butcher counter for brats and breakfast sausage to take home in a cooler. Then drive the 2.3 miles to the ReStore, and finish at Country Aire on a barn sale weekend. For a sit-down dinner afterward, there are more restaurants in Germantown, from a supper club on Main Street to a farmstead pizza hall on Pleasant View Drive.
If you are clearing out a house rather than filling one, the ReStore also takes furniture, appliances and building materials as donations, which can make the drive home lighter.
Pairing antiques with local history
If old things are the point of the trip, Dheinsville Historic Park holds a bell museum with more than 5,000 bells and an 1862 church, about 2.6 miles northwest of Pilgrim. Its museums open by appointment, so call ahead the same way you would for a barn sale.
A weekend can take in more: Germantown's parks, pubs and orchard winery are all within a few miles of Pilgrim Road.
Frequently asked questions
Published October 26, 2026














