Sunset Playhouse Elm Grove: Tickets, Fees and Parking

The 2026-27 season at Elm Grove's community theater on Wall Street, what tickets cost, how to skip the fee and where to eat first.

In Elm Grove, a village west of Milwaukee, Sunset Playhouse is the community theater, a not-for-profit company that has staged shows at 700 Wall Street since 1960. The theater's directions page says Wall Street is also known as Honorary Sunset Playhouse Way.

It is a busy stage for a village of 6,524 people: TMJ4 reported in July 2026 that the theater puts on about 36 shows a year, with casts drawn from the community and no precasting.

Sponsored

The Playhouse sits just south of Watertown Plank Road, and its listing names recent productions such as Legally Blonde, All Shook Up and Unnecessary Farce.

It also holds auditions for its shows and runs a School for the Arts.

What is on in the 2026-27 season

The main-stage season in the Furlan Auditorium opened with Lend Me a Tenor in September 2026 and runs to Mean Girls in summer 2027.

  • Annie, October 22 to November 8, 2026
  • 'Twas the Month Before Christmas, December 3 to 20, 2026
  • The Play That Goes Wrong, January 14 to 31, 2027
  • Always a Bridesmaid, March 4 to 21, 2027
  • Godspell, April 22 to May 9, 2027
  • Murder on the Orient Express, June 3 to 20, 2027
  • Mean Girls, July 15 to August 8, 2027

Off the main stage, the School for the Arts production Dorothy Meets Alice, for grades 7 to 12, runs October 24 to November 8, 2026, and the Musical MainStage Concert Series has a Bee Gees, Everly Brothers and Jacksons tribute on October 26 and 27.

Tickets, prices and fees

For Annie, the theater lists adult tickets at $29, with seniors 60 and over, students 13 and over and military at $27, and children 12 and under at $15. Groups of 10 or more pay $24 each, and the remaining Value Night, October 28, is $15 a seat. Annie runs about 2 hours 30 minutes, including a 15-minute intermission.

The tribute concert is cheaper, at $25 for adults and $23 for seniors, students and military, and runs about 90 minutes with no intermission.

Buying online adds $3.50 a ticket and buying by phone adds $1.50, while tickets bought at the box office window carry no fee. There are no refunds, but you can exchange into another performance of the same show up to 48 hours ahead. The box office number is (262) 782-4430, and the theater's own page gives two different sets of hours, so call before you walk over.

Two stages and a School for the Arts

Main-stage plays and musicals go up in the Furlan Auditorium, while the Marla Eichmann Studio Theater takes cabarets, children's shows and rentals. The company incorporated in 1954, opened its building in March 1960 with The Turn of the Screw, and added the studio theater in 1999.

The School for the Arts teaches ages 3 to 18 in weekly fall and winter sessions of acting, musical theater, improv and storytelling, among other subjects, and its bug in a rug program is for ages 2 to 8.

Parking, access and food rules

The theater's directions page describes free parking in its own lot, reached from the second driveway on Wall Street, but that page dates from 2023, so check when you book. A hearing loop is installed in the Furlan Auditorium for hearing aids and cochlear implants set to T-coil, and the box office handles wheelchair and accessible seating by phone.

Outside food and drink are not allowed, but the theater sells drinks and treats from Fazio's chocolate. Latecomers are seated at the back at a suitable break, so leave dinner with time to spare.

Dinner before the show

Zisters, about 0.15 miles north of the theater in the Elm Grove Park & Shop building, is the brunch and lunch stop before a matinee.

Its own site also lists evening hours later in the week, so check before an evening curtain.

Tavo's, about 0.05 miles from the theater, is the closest table, a Mexican restaurant with vegetarian, vegan and gluten-free choices on its listing.

O'Donoghue's Irish Pub, about a quarter mile north, is an old-style stone house with a patio, draft beer and broasted chicken.

Patch's calendar listed a Thursday show at the pub in September 2026.

Silver Spur's smoked barbecue and pizza at Za are also about a quarter mile north on Watertown Plank Road.

From bakery breakfasts to wine flights, the restaurants on Watertown Plank Road line the same few blocks.

Who is on stage

Casts are drawn from the community with no precasting, and the theater holds auditions for its productions. The theater's history page describes its Musical MainStage Concerts, SideNotes Cabarets and bug in a rug children's series as professional productions, run with volunteers and a small paid staff behind them.

For a holiday outing, 'Twas the Month Before Christmas plays December 3 to 20, 2026, and Value Nights at $15 a seat are the low-cost way in when a run offers them.

After the curtain

The theater is about half a mile from the Village Park, the other anchor of a day out in Elm Grove.

Frequently asked questions

Published October 12, 2026

You might also like

See all