Elm Grove Restaurants (Brunch to BBQ on Watertown Plank)

Eggs Benedict flights, artisan pizza, a smokehouse with a stone fireplace and a wine bar, all on one short stretch of road.

The Elm Grove restaurants worth knowing mostly sit on a short stretch of Watertown Plank Road, where the core of the row is under 0.2 miles end to end, so dinner, coffee and a drink after can all happen on foot. The row leans toward breakfast and lunch, with a smokehouse, a pizza kitchen, an Irish pub and a wine bar for the evening.

Two more, Culver's and Dumpling House, are on Bluemound Road to the south, and the Mexican spot is on Elm Grove Road near Sunset Playhouse.

Sponsored

Breakfast and brunch

Zisters, in the Elm Grove Park & Shop building, is the sit-down breakfast: its listing names eggs Benedict flights, omelets, tacos and mocha cappuccinos.

OnMilwaukee covered its 2018 opening, and OpenTable lists a patio and a full bar.

Its own site and OpenTable give different hours, so check the day you go.

Great Harvest Bread Co. bakes whole-grain breads and muffins from Montana wheat, and its online ordering page lists breakfast sandwiches, deli sandwiches and a daily soup. For coffee, Nona makes coffee, smoothies and acai bowls, plus butter coffee and low-carb options, in the space that used to hold Fairgrounds Coffee.

Pizza and Italian

Za makes handcrafted pizzas, pasta and meatballs for dine-in or takeout.

BizTimes reported in 2023 that Za comes from the Zierath Restaurant Group, the owners of Zisters, and that it was planned around wood-fired pizza.

Its online menu carries no date but lists a Margherita at $18, so treat prices as a guide.

Za is about 0.15 miles north of Zisters, so the two kitchens from the same owners sit on either side of the row.

Barbecue, pub food and the Friday fish fry

Silver Spur Texas Smokehouse BBQ serves smoked barbecue in a room with a stone fireplace.

Its website says the building dates to 1855 and promotes a Friday fish fry to go.

Call before you plan a Friday around it.

O'Donoghue's Irish Pub is an old-style stone house on Watertown Plank Road with a patio, draft beer, Irish pub food and broasted chicken. Its 2023 Visit Brookfield listing names fish and chips and shepherd's pie, and Patch's calendar listed a Thursday show at the pub in September 2026.

Mexican, dumplings and frozen custard

Tavo's At The Grove on Elm Grove Road is the Mexican option, and its listing notes vegetarian, vegan and gluten-free choices and online reservations.

Down on Bluemound Road, Dumpling House lists dumplings, stir-fried noodles and sushi rolls, with lunch and takeout.

Culver's, farther west on Bluemound, is the frozen custard and burger stop.

Picnic food for the park

For a picnic at the Village Park, Sendik's Food Market in the Park & Shop block sells deli and bakery food, wine and takeaway sushi, about half a mile from the park. About 0.1 miles away, Kettle Range Meat Company sells heat-and-eat meals such as Savory Swiss Steak and Spicy Shawarma alongside grass-fed beef and heritage pork.

Ice cream and something sweet

The Chocolate Factory scoops ice cream cones, sundaes and malts and also makes subs and croissant sandwiches. Milwaukee Record wrote in 2025 about eating a turkey sub at the Elm Grove location.

Drinks after dinner

Wine Down is the village wine bar, with flights, 2-ounce tasters and 4-ounce glasses from a list of more than 40 bottles and new flights each month.

The Journal Sentinel reported in May 2025 that it opened in December 2024 and that its flights are named after Elm Grove streets.

In season, the Elm Grove Beer Garden pours Third Space beer in the park, about 0.4 miles northwest of Wine Down.

Dinner before a show at Sunset Playhouse

Sunset Playhouse sits just south of the row: Zisters is about 0.15 miles north of the theater, and Silver Spur, Za and O'Donoghue's are each about a quarter mile north. Tavo's At The Grove is the closest table, about 0.05 miles from the theater by straight line.

The theater does not allow outside food or drink, though it sells drinks and treats from Fazio's chocolate. Ticket fees and parking for Sunset Playhouse are worth checking before you book a table.

For steakhouses and the mall dining rooms, the restaurants in Brookfield around Brookfield Square are the next step out.

Dinner on this row pairs with the rest of the things to do in Elm Grove, from the Village Park to the theater.

Frequently asked questions

Published October 5, 2026

You might also like

See all