The Buffalo Bar

Bar & PubWatertown, WisconsinHours

Local pub fare and loaded Bloody Marys on Church Street

CallWebsite

About

The Buffalo Bar is a bar in Watertown serving pub fare and cold drinks from our location on North Church Street. Pull up a stool at the counter for taps, bottles, and weekly menu specials. Our kitchen prepares classic pub staples including burgers, wings, chicken tenders, and onion rings. We also assemble elaborately garnished Bloody Marys topped with rotating additions such as hot dogs, jalapeño poppers, meatballs, cheese cubes, and beef sticks. Beyond food and drinks, we host community card games, including regular Sheepshead tournaments for local players.

mohawk ONE delta
2 months ago

Roaming by the area, not a bad place to graze, wandered into Buffalo and stayed for a phase. Hoofing through Watertown, hungry and dry, saw the watering hole and thought, why pass it by? Rumble and tumble, shuffle and stomp, belly to the bar for a buffalo romp. Cold taps tapping, bottles on ice, pour one honest and pour it up nice. Graze for a while, chew on some grub, shoot the old breeze in a neighborhood pub. Sip it and sup it, laugh with the herd, where stories get taller with every last word. No prairie required, no saddle, no horse, just roam with the buffalo watering-hole course. Horn to the left and a cold one to the right, graze through the day or roam into night. Hoofity-hoof and snortity-snore, one cold round might wander into four. Park your caboose, have a drink, have a think, then mosey on home from the Buffalo brink. Roaming the area? Not a bad place to graze. Wet your whistle and wander awhile through the haze. Where the herd gets heard and the cold taps flow, belly to the Buffalo, then buffalo slow. Forward, Wisconsin. Peace. Piece. Peas. Mr. E. & Justin Thyme

Tim Anderson
4 months ago

Excellent local pub with good fare. Wings, onion rings, burger, tenders all spot on. Bloody was tasty.

Lee Wallander
5 months ago

Visited here on 5/17/26. Place is apparently known for their bloody's. On that particular day, they put an entire hot dog on a bun on top. Also had cheese cube, piece of a beef stick, a meatball, and jalapeño popper, along with other veggies in the drink. Other days it apparently comes with a chicken sandwich or cheeseburger on top. So, if you are into Bloody Mary's, you should give this place a shot. Overall, a cool bar in Watertown.

Todd
a year ago

Good bar with good service. The drinks are well-priced.

Craig & Bernice
3 years ago

Nice size bar, bartender (Taylor) was very friendly. Food was decent, your typical bar food! Want to come back for the bloody on Sundays as most reviews state this is a MUST try!!

Review us

Frequently asked

  • What are your hours?

    Local time · GMT-6

    • Monday11:00 AM – 2:00 AM
    • Tue – Thu9:00 AM – 2:00 AM
    • Fri – Sat9:00 AM – 2:30 AM
    • Sunday9:00 AM – 12:00 AM
Watertown

While you're here

Explore more of Watertown

Everything local in Watertown, all in one place.

  • Every event coming up, from markets to live music
  • Places to eat, stay and visit nearby
  • Local guides from people who know the area

More Bar & Pubs nearby

The Score Sports Bar
Watertown
The Score Sports Bar

The Score Sports Bar

4.7(23)Bar & Pub
The Riff Dive Bar
Watertown
The Riff Dive Bar

The Riff Dive Bar

4.5(30)Bar & Pub
Uptown Bar & Grill
Watertown
Uptown Bar & Grill

Uptown Bar & Grill

4.3(348)Bar & Pub
Shotzy's Country Rock Bar
Oconomowoc14 mi
Shotzy's Country Rock Bar

Shotzy's Country Rock Bar

4.3(99)Bar & Pub
Oscar's Wine Bar
Hartford19 mi
Oscar's Wine Bar

Oscar's Wine Bar

4.9(15)Bar & Pub
Down Slope Pub
Hartford19 mi
Down Slope Pub

Down Slope Pub

4.6(99)Bar & Pub
The Drinking Well
Hartford19 mi
The Drinking Well

The Drinking Well

4.6(71)Bar & Pub
Doodles Bar
Hartford19 mi
Doodles Bar

Doodles Bar

4.5(43)Bar & Pub

Is this your business?

Reach people across town and nearby with The Buffalo Bar

Claim it free to post events, jobs and updates that show up on town pages, event calendars and local recommendations — and help local and AI search find you.

Claim this listing