Pinky Promise Coffee

Andrea Rose

4 weeks ago

We are in Sturgeon Bay for a few days and thought we would pick a different coffee spot each morning but this shop won me over on day one! The owner is so welcoming and friendly. I had the pumpkin spice iced coffee and my husband had the cinnamon roll hot coffee. Both were excellent. I plan on trying a new flavor each morning we are here.

Hannah Bolender

a month ago

Wonderful small cafe! Their Spanish latte was one of the best iced lattes I’ve ever had 😋 It’s attached to an art gallery as well.

Will

2 months ago

Wow! What a great experience at Pinky Promise! If you are looking for some coffee in Door County, don’t look any further, come straight here! The owner, Sammie, is absolutely kind and genuine. She took our orders for my fiancée and I, and we were blown away. She told us that the drinks they make are made from a special roast blend that her and her husband have mastered. INCREDIBLE. Top two coffees I’ve had in my life. We had their carrot cake latte and peach cobbler latte-both were amazing! Parking is easy and the shop was easy to find. Go check them out!

Elizabeth

3 months ago

We stopped late morning to get coffee for our last day of calling at Potowatomi State Park. It was easy to find and there was free on street parking nearby. The coffee was very good. In fact after drinking my toasted lady latte we ordered another round to go, plus the whole beans to take with. I appreciated that the owner seemed knowledgeable about the importance of growing bird friendly, shade grown, organic fair trade cooperative coffee. The cookies were delicious too! Would definitely stop here again. Appreciated the coffee bag decor too!

Rhonda Webb

5 months ago

My boyfriend and I stopped in on our way up to Sister Bay. Such a warm, inviting place. I didn’t verify but I’m pretty sure it was the owner who took and made our order. Wish I had gotten her name. She was so friendly and kind. We got there about 20 minutes before closing and knew they were probably trying to clean up and close down, but she was warm and friendly, even telling us we could sit and enjoy our drinks (we didn’t stay, though). Speaking of drinks—I had the S’mores latte (on the right in the picture) on her recommendation—and hands down it is one of the best lattes I’ve ever had…and I drink iced lattes almost daily! The espresso in this drink is top notch. My boyfriend had a London Fog and loved it. Without a doubt we’ll be back next time we’re in Door County (we live in Appleton).