Wood-fired pies and Wisconsin cheese curds on Bay Shore Drive
Recommended by
My fiancé and I visited Sister Bay on our honeymoon. We stopped at wild tomato pizza on our first night and loved it so much we came back two nights later. The Neapolitan pizza was solid but the hot honey pizza was our favorite. The pepperoni slices were huge and nicely thin. The hot honey added just enough bite and the goat cheese was smooth and sweet. It all was a very balanced pizza. The sausage pesto pizza satisfied our appetite.
Loved the margarita pizza had it two nights in a row!! The small was perfect size for my sisters and I! So tasty! Would recommend!!
On our 4th annual "kind-of-weekend" trip to Wisconsin, we stopped by this place in Sister Bay, and we're so glad we did! At first, we were a little hesitant, but that feeling disappeared the moment we were greeted by the warm and friendly staff. A special shout-out to Butler, who was incredibly kind, polite, and attentive. 🍕 The pizzas were absolutely delicious. The Thai Chili pizza was packed with flavor, and the Mediterranean pizza was hands-down our favorite—fresh, flavorful, and perfectly balanced. The regular pizza was great too, it could have used just a tiny bit more seasoning. The cheese curds were crispy, cheesy, and exactly what you want in Wisconsin. The garlic rolls were decent but didn't quite steal the show. The ambiance was pleasant and relaxing, making it a great place to unwind after exploring Sister Bay. Overall, a wonderful experience with great food, excellent service, and welcoming hospitality. 😄
Dinner stop while in Sister Bay. Had the hot honey and feta pizza. And the beet salad. Service was good and attentive. Atmosphere is fine, sorta a garage style.
Took the bikes for a ride and ended up here. Even on Memorial day weekend the wait was about 15 minutes, thought that was quick. Ordered cheese curds and a pizza. Both were great. The crust on the pizza was perfect for us, not too thin. Quality toppings.
Local time · GMT-6
While you're here
Everything local in Sister Bay, all in one place.
Is this your business?
Reach people across town and nearby with Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza & Grille Sister Bay
Claim it free to post events, jobs and updates that show up on town pages, event calendars and local recommendations — and help local and AI search find you.
Claim this listing
