The Wisco An Old Fashioned Supper Club is an American restaurant in Le Roy. We offer classic supper club dining and a menu featuring steak, prime rib, and a Friday night fish fry.
We also serve traditional ice cream cocktails such as the Grasshopper and Brandy Alexander, along with other classic drinks.
1st time at the Wisco. The hostess, bartenders and server were fantastic. We had a party of 4. Prime Rib, Fillets, Salmon and scallops were excellent. I personally met the owner, super nice guy. Brandy Alexander’s and creme brulee for dessert were Great as well. I highly recommend visiting the Wisco!!!
Dawn Doyle
2 months ago
This was our first time here. We came after a brewer game so the original reservation we made, we came very late for. They made no mention and made a us all welcome. We had a group of eight, which included a couple of younger people. We ordered everything from sandwiches to prime rib dinners. Everything came out together and was delicious ! The entire staff was friendly and excellent service. I can’t wait until we go back again.
Jason Stange
5 months ago
Best french onion soup I have ever had. The stag is amazing. Food is great. This place is a must stop. I should have taken a pic of the French onion before we inhaled it.
Mark Devino
10 months ago
I guess it’s an old format for supper clubs, but here’s how it works. You’re given a playing card by the host and left at the somewhat small, crowded bar. Later on your table server comes and gets the order from everyone that will be at the table. In a few minutes the server returns to take you to your table. You pay your bar bill and head to the dining room. The table is already set with bread and the relish tray. Entrees were ordered while in the bar, so now you have some time to enjoy your company and cocktails. Between four of us we ordered the BBQ ribs, an 8oz filet, the Lemon Pepper Baked Salmon and the prime rib. All were very good but not great. I would pass on the haystack onion rings. Kind of undercooked and messy. Wisco is a very legitimate supper club, you’ll have a good time.
Tom Conway
a year ago
You check in at the door, get a playing card, and wait with a drink. Waitstaff comes out to the bar to take your order while you’re still standing there. No dining at the bar. No reservations and no wait.
Bar is tight but well-stocked. Drinks came fast—Old Fashioned was on the sweeter side, but balanced. Dining room has that classic supper club look—low ceilings, red glass candles, and wallpaper that hasn’t changed in decades.
Relish tray was basic but generous: club crackers, cheese spread, pickled beets, and chips that looked like they came from a bag. Baked potato was over-the-top with bacon and cheddar. Fried cod was light and flaky, better than expected. Portion wasn’t huge, but everything came hot.
Service was efficient and friendly. No long gaps, no small talk. Dining room gets loud once it fills up, but still easy to hold a conversation.
Overall, a traditional supper club doing what you’d expect—no frills, no drama, just reliable food and a predictable rhythm
Take and bake pizzas prepared on South Park Avenue
Is this your business?
Reach people across town and nearby with The Wisco An Old Fashioned Supper Club
Claim it free to post events and updates that show up on town pages, event calendars and local recommendations — and help local and AI search find you.