House-made gelato and freshly pressed cones on Main Street
Recommended by
Such a cute little place, the gelato is super creamy and made in the shop. You can sample flavors before you decide on one and I will say a small dish will let you put two flavors in there and it’s plenty for one person. I would highly recommend their cardamom maple if you’re visiting in the fall.
We had a slight scheduling mix-up on our first attempt to visit, but the owner reached out directly and went above and beyond to make things right. That level of customer care is rare, so we gladly gave them another visit—and we were blown away! We’ve been searching for a place that replicates the superb gelato we had on our Spring trip to Italy, and Sara’s Artisan Gelato nailed it. The gelato is rich and authentic, the waffle cones are freshly made in-shop, and the employee helping us was incredibly patient and kind. It was fabulous from start to finish. This will officially be a must-stop on our annual Door County trips!
We had a great experience here! Staff was amazing and offered plenty of samples. Really kind and genuine staff. We loved our choices. Highly recommend the cherry gelato. We walked outside to eat our treats and saw a ridiculous sign posted by a neighboring bakery about not eating gelato in their ice cream area (inset eye roll) After we finished our gelato we went into the bakery to see the inside. While we didn’t order anything, the staff didn’t acknowledge us and I already felt annoyed by the sign outside. Just a weird sign to post about your neighbor business. Maybe the place is amazing but they won’t get my business with a sign bickering with another shop. It just seemed petty
This is a must stop in Fish Creek. Small, cute and amazing selection of delicious gelato and sorbets. Staff is so amazing. We will be back (pretty much everyday we are here!
Stopped by the Fish Creek location, great gelato and even better staff! I had biscoff cookie and unicorn batter, friend got dirt cake batter and cherry. Absolutely scrumptious. The girl serving us, believe her name was Kira? Was SO sweet and kind! Offered us samples and chatted with us for a little while nobody was in. Definitely will be back for both!
Local time · GMT-6
While you're here
Everything local in Fish Creek, all in one place.
Is this your business?
Reach people across town and nearby with Sara's Artisan Gelato
Claim it free to post events, jobs and updates that show up on town pages, event calendars and local recommendations — and help local and AI search find you.
Claim this listing
